Who is Allah?

Reading settings

Text size

Easier reading

More space between lines and letters, plain font for headings, no italics.

Calm mode

No moving backgrounds or animations; softer images.

Save data

No background video and no card photos: good on a slow or capped connection.

Saved on this device only. Nothing is sent to us.

Fiṭra · Romans 1 · Isaiah 44 · God-kings · Nature

Why have people worshipped kings, the Sun and idols?

For thousands of years people bowed to rulers, stars and carved figures. The scriptures read this as a real instinct, pointed the wrong way.

Photo: Diego Delso, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Why we give thanks · Why have people worshipped kings, the Sun and idols?

Next: How many gifts keep you alive while you… →

In ancient Egypt, the king carried the title “son of Ra”, the Sun god, and was treated as a god on earth. In Rome, two years after Julius Caesar was murdered, the Senate declared him a god, and later emperors were honoured with temples and sacrifices. Across the world, people have bowed to the Sun and Moon, to rivers and mountains, and to figures carved from wood and stone.

Why? One answer runs through all three Abrahamic scriptures. Human beings are made to give thanks and to worship. That pull is real and good. The only question is where it points.

“And of His portents are the night and the day and the sun and the moon. Do not prostrate to the sun or the moon; but prostrate to Allah Who created them, if it is in truth Him Whom ye worship.”

Qur'an 41:37 · Pickthall (1930)

The verse does not mock people who honoured the Sun. It agrees that the Sun and Moon are worth wondering at; it calls them signs. It simply follows the wonder one step further, from the gift to the Giver.

What scholars of religion say

Scholars have argued for over a century about how religion began. In the 1800s, many assumed that humans started with spirits and nature worship and slowly “progressed” to belief in one God. In the early 1900s the Austrian scholar Wilhelm Schmidt argued the reverse: many peoples, including some of the oldest hunter-gatherer cultures, already believed in a High God, a distant Creator, alongside lesser spirits. Neither theory is accepted today in its strong form. The evidence is patchy and varied. Our page on the High God tells that story.

Historians of the ancient world point out that god-kings were useful to kings. A ruler who is divine is hard to argue with. That is one reason the Hebrew prophets, and later the Prophet Muhammad, are remembered for standing up to powerful people in the name of one God. The Qur'an remembers Pharaoh announcing, “And proclaimed: "I (Pharaoh) am your Lord the Highest.".” (79:24, Pickthall).

Cognitive scientists of religion add another angle. Minds that are quick to sense someone behind every sound would easily sense spirits in storms, stars and rivers. See our page on why practices look so alike.

42 BCERome's Senate declares Julius Caesar a god
“son of Ra”a title of Egypt's kings for over 2,000 years
Isaiah 44a prophet's sharp satire on carving your own god

Watch

Watch

For everyone

Exhibition Tour—Divine Egypt | Met ExhibitionsThe Met · 17 minThe Met's tour of 'Divine Egypt': how Egyptians pictured gods and god-kings.

What each faith says

Read:

Judaism

“He burneth the half thereof in the fire; With the half thereof he eateth flesh; He roasteth roast, and is satisfied; … And the residue thereof he maketh a god, even his graven image; He falleth down unto it and worshippeth, and prayeth unto it, And saith: ‘Deliver me, for thou art my god.’”

Isaiah 44:16–17 · JPS 1917

The Hebrew prophets are sharp about idols. Isaiah describes a man who cuts down a tree, burns half of it to cook his dinner and warm his hands, then carves the rest into a god and prays to it. The point is not that the man is stupid. It is that he has forgotten who gave him the tree, the fire and the bread. A well-known Jewish story says Abraham grew up in his father's idol shop and smashed the idols (Genesis Rabbah 38:13).

Christianity

“Because knowing God, they didn’t glorify him as God, and didn’t give thanks, but became vain in their reasoning, and their senseless heart was darkened. Professing themselves to be wise, they became fools, and traded the glory of the incorruptible God for the likeness of an image of corruptible man, and of birds, four-footed animals, and creeping things.”

Romans 1:21–23 · World English Bible (British Edition), public domain

Paul wrote to Christians in Rome, the city of god-emperors. He says that God's power can be seen in what He made, so people have always had a clue (Romans 1:20). The trouble, he says, was not that people did not know. It was that they did not give thanks, and swapped the Creator for images of people and animals.

Islam

“Lo! I have turned my face toward Him Who created the heavens and the earth, as one by nature upright, and I am not of the idolaters.”

Qur'an 6:79 · Pickthall (1930)

The Qur'an says every person is made with fiṭra, a natural readiness to recognise the Creator (30:30). It tells how the young Abraham looked at a bright star, then the Moon, then the Sun, and called each one “my Lord”, until each one set. The story treats nature worship as an honest search that stopped too soon. Abraham's answer was to look past what sets to the One who never does.

Without religion

A non-religious reader may see god-kings as a tool of power, and nature worship as early science: a first attempt to explain the weather and the seasons. Many would agree with the prophets on one thing. No ruler should ever be treated as a god.

Sikhi

“Were he to obtain a great name and praise and renown in the world; If God's look of favour fell not on him, no one would notice him.”

Guru Granth Sahib, ang 2 (Japji, pauri 7) · Max Arthur Macauliffe, The Sikh Religion (1909), public domain

Sikh teaching holds that God is nirankar, without form, yet present in all creation, and it does not use images in worship. Guru Nanak also refused to treat rulers as more than human. In the Japji he says that even the most famous person is nothing without God's favour.

Hindu traditions

Hindus worship God through murtis, sacred images in homes and mandirs. A murti is not thought of as God made of stone. It is consecrated as a place where God's presence is honoured, and a focus for love, so that worshippers may receive darshan, a loving sight of the divine. Many Hindus are hurt when this is called “idol worship”, a label given by outsiders. Some Hindu reformers, such as Dayananda Saraswati in the 1800s, taught worship without images; most Hindus still use them.

Beyond the Abrahamic faiths

Many indigenous peoples honour the land, rivers and animals as gifts, and some speak of a Creator above them. Their elders often describe this as respect and gratitude rather than worship of the river itself. In ancient Greece, the thinker Xenophanes mocked gods made in human shape: if horses could draw, he said, they would draw gods that looked like horses.

Same and different

Jews, Christians and Muslims tell this story in three voices: an inborn sense of God, and a habit of pointing it at the wrong thing, whether a king, a star or a carved figure. All three answer with one Creator who cannot be pictured. Sikhs agree that God has no form. Hindus describe sacred images differently, as a way to honour the One who is present everywhere, and deserve to be heard in their own words. What almost everyone shares is the pull itself: an instinct to thank and honour something greater than ourselves.

A moment to reflect

  1. Why might a king want people to think he was a god?
  2. Abraham noticed that the stars, Moon and Sun all set. What does “I like not those that set” mean to you?
  3. Paul says the root problem was not giving thanks. Do you agree that forgetting thanks can lead people astray?
  4. What do people today give the kind of attention that others once gave to kings or idols?

Do it together

schools / familiesMuseum visit

Visit the Egyptian or Roman galleries of a museum such as the British Museum. Find a king shown as a god. Talk about who gained from that picture, and who did not.

community groupsAsk, don't assume

Visit a mandir and ask a member of the community to explain what a murti means to them. Write down their words, not your own guesses.

familiesThe setting star

Go out on a clear evening. Watch a star or the Moon move across the sky over an hour. Read the story of Abraham in Qur'an 6:76–79 and talk about it.

Go deeper

In pictures

The standing stones of Stonehenge under a dark, stormy sky.
The standing stones of Stonehenge under a dark, stormy sky. Photo: Diego Delso, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons
The temple of Karnak reflected in its sacred lake at Luxor, Egypt.
The temple of Karnak reflected in its sacred lake at Luxor, Egypt. Photo: Taranis-iuppiter, CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons
Aerial view of the vast Karnak temple complex beside the Nile.
Aerial view of the vast Karnak temple complex beside the Nile. Photo: Ahmed Bahloul Khier Galal, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons
Sources (10)
  1. Isaiah 44:13–17 text: Sefaria, JPS 1917
  2. Romans 1:20–23 text: World English Bible (British Edition) via bible-api.com
  3. Qur'an 41:37, 6:76–79, 30:30, 79:24 meanings (rendered Pickthall (1930) where quoted): Quran.com
  4. Abraham and his father's idols: Genesis Rabbah 38:13 (Sefaria)
  5. Japji pauri 7 in Macauliffe's translation: Max Arthur Macauliffe, The Sikh Religion, vol. 1 (1909), Wikisource
  6. Murti as a means of experiencing the divine presence; Dayananda Saraswati's dissent: RE Online (Culham St Gabriel's), Images and image worship
  7. Julius Caesar deified by the Senate in 42 BCE (Divus Iulius): Wikipedia, Imperial cult of ancient Rome
  8. 'Son of Ra' (sa-Ra) as a royal title of Egypt's kings: Wikipedia, Ancient Egyptian royal titulary
  9. Wilhelm Schmidt and Urmonotheismus: Wikipedia, Wilhelm Schmidt (linguist)
  10. Xenophanes: if horses could draw (fragment B15): Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, Xenophanes

Watch more: Why have people worshipped kings, the Sun and idols?

5 films and talks, chosen for this page. They play here.

  • Religion in Pre-Islamic Arabia

    Let's Talk Religion · 23 min

    Let's Talk Religion: religion in pre-Islamic Arabia.

  • The Gods of Pre-Islamic Arabia

    ReligionForBreakfast · 31 min

  • Akhenaten: The First Monotheist? | Atenism

    ReligionForBreakfast · 31 min

  • Monotheism, Images, Idols – Abdal Hakim Murad

    Cambridge Muslim College · 25 min

  • More films and talks on F-ILMWatch free