Beware the Messiah

Read on

Dune: Part Three, drawn from Frank Herbert's second novel Dune Messiah, is due in cinemas on 18 December 2026. Before it arrives, hear what Herbert himself said the story was about. Many viewers leave Dune: Part Two cheering for Paul Atreides as he rises from refugee to messiah. Herbert would have been worried by the cheering.

A warning, in the author's own words

In an essay called “Dune Genesis”, published in Omni magazine in July 1980, Herbert explained that he had imagined the whole trilogy as one book “about the messianic convulsions that periodically overtake us”. The idea grew, he said, “from my theory that superheroes are disastrous for humankind”. And he spelled out the lesson plainly: “Don't give over all of your critical faculties to people in power, no matter how admirable those people may appear to be.”

“Heroes are painful, superheroes are a catastrophe.” Frank Herbert, “Dune Genesis”, Omni, July 1980

Denis Villeneuve, who directed the films, has said that Herbert “wanted the book to be a warning”. That is why he gave Chani a larger part than she has in the novel. In Part Two she loves Paul, and she is also the one who will not kneel. When the crowds roar, she walks away. The audience is meant to see Paul through her eyes.

A religion made to order

In Dune, the prophecy Paul fulfils was planted on purpose. Generations earlier, a sisterhood called the Bene Gesserit seeded legends among desert peoples so that one day they could be used. Paul knows it. He uses it anyway. The film borrows words from Arabic and Islamic tradition, Mahdi among them, but this is not the Mahdi of Islam: it is faith turned into a tool.

All three Abrahamic traditions have their own version of Herbert's warning, and they gave it long before him. The Torah says that even a prophet who performs a sign or a wonder must not be followed if he leads people away from God: “If there arise in the midst of thee a prophet, or a dreamer of dreams, and he give thee a sign or a wonder … thou shalt not hearken unto the words of that prophet” (Deuteronomy 13:2–4, JPS 1917). Jesus warns that “there will arise false christs, and false prophets, and they will show great signs and wonders, so as to lead astray, if possible, even the chosen ones” (Matthew 24:24, WEB). The First Letter of John adds: “don't believe every spirit, but test the spirits” (1 John 4:1, WEB). Islamic tradition warns of the Dajjāl, the great deceiver who will come with wonders, and Muslim history remembers many who falsely claimed to be the Mahdi.

The Qur'an puts the principle in one line: do not follow what you have no knowledge of, because hearing, sight and heart will all be asked about (17:36, in brief). Faith, in all three traditions, is meant to keep the conscience awake, not to put it to sleep.

Seeing the future, and the unseen

Paul's great gift is prescience: he sees possible futures. On screen it looks like power; in the books it becomes a trap. Herbert wrote that wanting an absolute prediction means you “want only today, and you reject tomorrow”. The more clearly Paul sees, the fewer choices he believes he has, until he walks into the war he dreaded because every vision tells him he must.

The scriptures draw a firm line here. Some knowledge belongs to God alone. “The secret things belong unto the LORD our God; but the things that are revealed belong unto us and to our children for ever” (Deuteronomy 29:28, JPS 1917). When the disciples ask Jesus about the future, he answers: “It isn't for you to know times or seasons which the Father has set within his own authority” (Acts 1:7, WEB). The Qur'an says that with God are the keys of the unseen, and no one knows them but Him (6:59, in brief). Among the 99 Names, al-ʿAlīm, the All-Knowing, and al-Khabīr, the All-Aware, describe a knowledge that sees everything without being trapped by it. Paul's tragedy is a human trying to hold a knowledge that only the One who is not bound by time could hold.

Love, and the one who would not kneel

Chani's love for Paul is real, and it is exactly what lets her see what the crowds cannot. Love here is not blind; it is the clearest sight in the film. The Qur'an calls love and mercy between two people one of God's signs (30:21, in brief), and the Names include al-Wadūd, the Loving. Love that tells the truth to the person it loves is close to what the faiths mean.

The Guide who wants you awake

What separates Paul from real guidance? Herbert's answer: beware anyone who asks you to stop thinking. The faiths agree, in their own words. Among the Names, al-Hādī is the Guide and ar-Rashīd the Guide to the right path. In the Qur'an, guidance arrives with an invitation again and again: reflect, look, use your reason, ask. Al-Ḥaqq, the Truth, does not need a crowd to shout it into being. The test Herbert offers is a fair one for any of us, believer or not. Does this voice make me kinder, more honest and more awake? Or does it ask me to hand my conscience to someone else?

• Frank Herbert, “Dune Genesis”, Omni, July 1980: text of the essay. Short quotations for criticism and review.
• Dune: Part Two (2024), dir. Denis Villeneuve; Legendary and Warner Bros.
• Dune: Part Three, release date: Wikipedia
• Hebrew Bible, JPS 1917 (Deuteronomy 13:2–4; 29:28): Sefaria
• New Testament, World English Bible (Matthew 24:24; Acts 1:7; 1 John 4:1): Bible Gateway
• Qur'an 6:59, 17:36, 30:21, in brief: quran.com